|
‘Lovely and Amazing’ (Lions Gate, 2001)
Directed by Nicole Holofcener
I’m sure a lot of guys will avoid renting this because
it’s a “chick flick”. That’s too bad, because good films transcend gender,
and ‘Lovely and Amazing’ is a good film. No “action”. No violence. Not
much sex. Just a well written, well acted film about real people. The film
concerns itself with the lives of Jane Marks (Brenda Blethyn) and her family. Her
two genetic daughters - failed artist Michelle (Kathryn Keener) and up and coming
actress Elizabeth (Emily Mortimer) - and her adopted child, a pre-teen black girl named
Annie (Raven Goodwin).
Jake (Donnie Darko) Glyllenhal also turns in a nice supporting performance
as Jordan, Michelle's teenage boss.
As the film starts, the two grown daughters are in
unfulfilling relationships, mom is going in for liposuction, and Annie is
clearly having issues. This could easily be the recipe for Oprah endorsed
schmaltz. Thanks to an intelligent screenplay and excellent performances,
however, ‘Lovely and Amazing’ gracefully sidesteps the cloying
sentimentality and phoniness often exhibited by this sort of material.
We’re essentially dealing here with issues of women’s
fulfillment, and how the media shapes people’s self image. ‘Lovely and
Amazing’ never gets preachy, though. Men are not portrayed as insensitive
louts who don’t understand their women. In fact, Elizabeth's boyfriend
understands her better than she does herself. And even though
Michelle's husband is
cheating on her, he’s not portrayed as a complete asshole. The main focus of
the story, however, is Annie. Struggling with her identity, reaching out for
attention, when her mom tells her that the liposuction surgery she’s
undergoing is to “make an improvement” she sees no reason why she shouldn’t
try to make herself appear more white.
Hollywood’s idea of good starring role for a woman is
something like Meg Ryan in ‘Kate and Leopold’; a phony, one dimensional
caricature just waiting for some time traveler from the romantic past to
come and sweep her off her feet. Movies like ‘Lovely and Amazing’ that
actually give an actress something to sink her teeth into are far too rare.
Don’t pass this one up. (Bob Ignizio) |
'Pumpkin' (MGM, 2002)
Directed by Adam Larson Broder and Anthony Abrams
Is it too much to expect that a movie have a consistent
tone? That’s all I’m asking for. ‘Pumpkin’ is the story of a vapid
sorority girl (Christina Ricci) whose volunteer work with the mentally and
physically challenged character of the title (played by Hank Harris) leads to something like
romance. It’s a delicate subject matter, and you can either handle it with
warmth and taste, or go for full on John Waters-esque camp. Unfortunately,
this movie wants to have it both ways, and it just doesn’t work. Warning to
Christina fans – she sucks in this movie. I don’t blame her, though. If
even the filmmakers don’t know what tone they're going for, how can the
actress figure it out?
First of all, the self absorbed “popular girl” shtick
has been done to death. ‘Pumpkin’ is clearly striving for the level of
satire attained by ‘Heathers’, but winds up nearer to the depths of bad teen
comedy. Yes, I get it. Girls in sororities are ignorant and self
absorbed. Is it really necessary to waste half this movie’s running time on
that? Apparently so, as the movie takes frequent diversions from the main
plot to focus on the stupidity and shallowness of Christina and her
sisters.
That brings us to our next problem. This is an hour
and a half movie painfully stretched to two hours. A decent editor could
have easily excised several pointless asides, mostly involving Christina’s
hunk boyfriend playing tennis. Did they think that if they made it longer,
it would seem more like a serious character driven independent film? For
characters to drive a film, they have to be more than cardboard
stereotypes. They need to have depth and humanity. There’s none of that on
display here.
There are occasional laughs in ‘Pumpkin’. Even one or
two scenes that come close to achieving emotional resonance. If the
directors could have just made up their mind on what kind of movie this was
supposed to be, and made the necessary cuts, this might have been a worthy
“B” picture. Instead it’s just a schizophrenic mess. (Bob Ignizio) |